I have been having some deep discussions about art, ideas, patterns & copyrights with several artists lately. It seems that there are people that think it's ok to take someone else's pattern & reproduce it many times over, & sell it, saying it's their own because they made it, & feel no guilt in this act. Crafters have been doing it for ages, therefore it's ok , right? Is a simple idea copyrightable?  Is it ethically proper to take someone else's pattern, produce the product, and then place a tag on it stating it's your original?  Is this just taking and using someone's pattern or just using a particular technique, as the craft person stated?

What's right & what's wrong? I don't like doing patterns because I really want my work to be my own. I enjoy teaching others, but feel like I've had something stolen from me when a student took my envelope style Reverse-A-Purse, & started selling them here in our small community without ever asking me.

I think this may mean some bad Kharma for her. I think it is a life lesson for me & will forever change the way I teach. I would like to make others more aware that there are some moral & ethical issues here, even if legally Copyright Law is so darned ambiguous that it can be argued until we're all blue in the face, & still never be solved.

The bottom line is ASK. Ask for permission before you start reproducing something you learn from someone else. It'll save you some heartaches.

Powered by Prime Territory